Hungry now?

Call ahead to order!

516-541-7415

Quality like this can't be outsourced!

Stuff A Bagel logo

Stuff a Bagel serves breakfast and lunch 7 days a week at our Carman's Plaza store. Take-out orders are welcome, or we can deliver to your home or office. Remember us for your next office party, wedding shower or club picnic. We cater!

Let's do lunch

Stuff a Bagel does a bang-up job with lunch, too! All bagels and pastries are baked fresh daily in our store.  

 

We make our signature sandwiches exclusively with Boar's Head cold cuts, and you won't find iceberg lettuce in any of our salads.

 -  Fresh-baked bagels, muffins and cookies sold individually or by the dozen

 -  Cream cheese and lox spread sold by the pound

 -  Omelets, pancakes, french toast, wraps, salads

We're up with the sun to serve you

Square Square

"Stuff a Bagel has the best onion bagel I've ever had, very fresh. Great food and great service."

- Stephanie M.

OPEN DAILY 4.30 AM

"Very tasty bagels. The price  is slightly higher, but well worth the extra coin."

- Kaye O.

Enjoy the difference at our place or yours

It's said that breakfast is the most important meal of the day, and Stuff a Bagel agrees! We also know that New Yorkers are early risers, so we open our doors at 4:30 AM, even on Sundays. Start your day with a quick, delicious breakfast with us.

You can take it with you

Square Lox Bagel

Egg Sandwiches

On a bagel or roll

Croissant .50¢ extra, hero $1.00 extra, wrap .50¢ extra

1. 2 Eggs ........................................................................................... $2.75

2. 2 Eggs with Cheese .................................................................. 2.85

3. 2 Eggs with Ham ....................................................................... 3.05

4. 2 Eggs with Bacon .................................................................... 3.05

5. 2 Eggs with Sausage ............................................................... 3.05

6. 2 Eggs with Ham & Cheese ................................................. 3.40

7. 2 Eggs with Bacon & Cheese .............................................. 3.45

8. 2 Eggs with Sausage & Cheese ......................................... 3.45

9. 2 Eggs with Ham, Bacon, Sausage & Cheese ............ 4.59

10. 2 Egg Whites ............................................................................. 2.75

11. 2 Egg Whites with Broccoli & Mushrooms ............... 3.45

12. 2 Egg Whites with Sausage .............................................. 3.05

13. Hungry Man - 2 Eggs with Ham, Sausage, Bacon

Home Fries and 12 oz. Coffee ................................................ 5.79

14. 3 Egg Whites with Turkey .................................................. 3.40

 

Omelettes

Served with Home Fries

Cheese - Your choice of cheese .......................................... $4.49

Ham or Bacon ................................................................................. 4.59

Western - Ham, Peppers & Onions ...................................... 4.59

Spanish - Peppers & Onions .................................................... 4.59

Mushrooms & Broccoli ............................................................... 4.59

Steak & Eggs ..................................................................................... 5.39

Potato & Eggs ................................................................................... 5.29

Italian - Sundried Tomatoes, Sausage & Mozzarella  4.99

Lox, Onion & Eggs .......................................................................... 5.99

Egg Whites, Low-Fat Swiss, Turkey ...................................... 4.99

Vegetable - Peppers, Onions, Broccoli, Spinach,

& Tomatoes with Egg Whites .................................................. 5.49

 

Pancakes & French Toast

Pancakes - 3 Jumbo Pancakes made to order

with Home Fries ........................................................................... $5.49

French Toast - 3 thick slices made to order

with Home Fries ............................................................................. 5.49

 

Melts

Ham & Cheese Melt ................................................................... $6.10

Turkey - Your choice of melted cheese ............................ 6.10

Tuna Melt - Your choice of melted cheese ..................... 6.15

Heavenly Style Chicken Cutlet with Bacon,

Melted Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato ...................................... 6.69

Pastami Melt with Swiss Cheese .......................................... 6.69

RESTAURANT MENU

Boar's Head Signature Sandwiches

All lunch sandwiches include a side salad & pickle

- Bagel, roll or wrap $6.50 -

- Hero $7.50-

 

SOHO - Oven Gold Turkey, Bacon, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo

TEXAN - Roast Beef & Melted Cheddar with BBQ Sauce

L.I. BOATER - Ever Roast Chicken, Provolone Cheese, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Oil & Vinegar

NEW ORLEANS - Buffalo Chicken, Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, with Bleu Cheese Dressing

DIETER'S DELIGHT - Honey Maple Turkey, Lacey Swiss, Lettuce & Honey Mustard on a Whole Wheat Bagel or Roll

BRONX - Deluxe Ham, Mozzarella Cheese, Sundried Tomatoes & Honey Mustard

MANHATTAN - Hot Pastrami & Melted Mozzarella with Spicy Mustard

OLD SMOKEY - Smoked Turkey & Smoked Gouda Cheese topped with Sundried Tomato Mayo

REUBEN - Hot Corned Beef, Melted Swiss Cheese, with Sauerkraut & Russian Dressing

HAMPTON - Cracked Pepper Turkey & Muenster Cheese topped with Cole Slaw

VIRGINIAN - Virginia Ham, American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

ALL AMERICAN BBQ - Boar's Head Chicken, Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onion

CHIPOTLE - Boar's Head Chipotle Chicken, Smoked Gouda, Lettuce & Tomato

GODFATHER - Ham, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Onions with Oil & Vinegar

DAGWOOD - Turkey, Roast Beef, Bologna, Ham, American Cheese, Lettuce & Tomatoes

 

 

 

Lunch Specials

Served with a side salad & pickle

On bread, bagel, roll or wrap. Wrap .50¢ extra,

Croissant .50¢ extra, Hero $1.00 extra

 

Honey Glazed Turkey ............................................................... $5.69

Smoked Turkey ............................................................................... 5.69

Oven Gold Turkey ......................................................................... 5.69

Cracked Peppermill Turkey .................................................... 5.69

Bologna ............................................................................................... 4.69

Roast Beef ......................................................................................... 5.69

Ham ...................................................................................................... 5.69

Genoa Salami .................................................................................. 5.69

Pastrami .............................................................................................. 5.69

Corned Beef ...................................................................................... 5.69

Buffalo Chicken Breast .............................................................. 5.79

Ever Roast Chicken Breast. ...................................................... 5.79

All American BBQ Chicken Breast ....................................... 5.79

Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato ......................................................... 5.19

Whitefish ............................................................................................ 6.79

Tuna ...................................................................................................... 5.79

Chicken Salad .................................................................................. 5.79

Apple Cranberry Chicken Salad ............................................ 5.89

Egg Salad ............................................................................................ 4.59

Cheese Sandwich ........................................................................... 4.59

 

Gourmet Hot Heros

CUBANO - Pulled Pork, Ham, Melted Swiss, Tomato

& Pickle on a Grilled Garlic hero

$7.50

 

MINEOLA - Chicken Cutlet, Cappy Ham, Melted

Provolone with Lettuce & Tomato on a hero

7.50

 

PEPPER STEAK - Steak & Peppers with

Special Sauce on a hero

7.50

 

PHILLY CHEESESTEAK - Steak, Onions, Peppers,

Mushrooms, Melted Cheese & Gravy on a Toasted Garlic hero

7.50

Chicken Cutlet Wraps

- $6.99-

 

GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR WRAP - Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese & Caesar Dressing

RANCH WRAP - Grilled Chicken, American Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Ranch Dressing

FRIED CHICKEN WRAP - With Mozzarella Cheese and Red Roasted Peppers

BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP - Fried Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomato, Hot Sauce & Bleu Cheese

GREEK GRILLED CHICKEN - Feta Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Green Peppers with Greek Dressing

 

Garden Salads

 

HOUSE SALAD - Mesculean Lettuce, Romaine, Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Onions, Carrots & Cucumbers

$5.49

 

GREEK SALAD - Romaine Lettuce, Green Peppers, Onions, Tomatoes, Carrots & Feta Cheese

6.99

 

CAESAR SALAD - Grilled Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Grated Cheese & Caesar Dressing

6.99

 

CHEF SALAD - Mesculean Lettuce, Romaine, Tomatoes, Green Peppers, Onions with Lacey Swiss Cheese, Turkey & Ham

6.99

 

HIBACHI CHICKEN SALAD - Fresh Spring Mix & Raspberry Vinaigrette Dressing

6.99

 

FRUIT SALAD - Cantaloupe, Honeydew, Pineapple, Grapes, Strawberries & Blueberries

4.50

 

Salads

Priced per pound

 

Potato, Macaroni, Coleslaw ......................................... $3.59

Redskin Potato ....................................................................... 3.69

Tuna Salad ................................................................................ 8.89

Chicken Salad ......................................................................... 8.89

Apple Cranberry Chicken Salad ................................... 9.89

Egg Salad ................................................................................... 8.89

Whitefish ................................................................................. 11.50

ALL PRICES ARE SUBJECT TO CHANGE. PRICES DO NOT INCLUDE TAX.

Spreads on Bagels or Rolls

Butter ................................................................................................. $1.84

Cream Cheese ................................................................................. 2.53

Mixed Cream Cheese .................................................................. 2.99

Lox Spread ........................................................................................ 3.05

Butter & Jelly ................................................................................... 1.95

Cream Cheese & Jelly ................................................................. 2.65

Peanut Butter & Jelly ................................................................... 2.65

Cream Cheese & Nova Lox ...................................................... 6.99

 

Cream Cheese

Priced per pound

Plain $7.35 - Mixed $8.79 - Lox Spread $9.79

 

Beverages

 

Coffee, Tea or Hot Chocolate

Small $1.69 - Medium $1.85 - Large $1.95

Snapple ............................................................................................... 1.70

Soda (Can) ......................................................................................... .92¢

Soda (20 oz.) ..................................................................................... 1.84

Gatorade ............................................................................................ 1.80

Tropicana 1 OOZ ........................................................................... 1.60

Tropicana 14/16oz. ...................................................................... 1.99

Chocolate Milk ............................................................................... 1.95

Water .............................................................................. 1.25/1.75/2.50

Arizona ................................................................................................ .99¢

Boar's Head Cold Cuts

Priced per pound

Ham ......................................................................................... $10.75

Oven Gold Turkey .............................................................. 10.75

Honey Maple Turkey ........................................................ 10.75

Smoked Turkey .................................................................... 10.75

Cracked Peppermill Turkey ......................................... 10.75

Buffalo Chicken ................................................................... 10.75

Ever Roast Chicken ........................................................... 10.75

All American BBQ Chicken ........................................... 10.75

Bologna ...................................................................................... 5.50

Genoa Salami ....................................................................... 10.75

Pepperoni ............................................................................... 10.75

Corned Beef .......................................................................... 10.75

Pastrami .................................................................................. 10.75

Roast Beef .............................................................................. 10.75

American Cheese .................................................................. 7.09

Swiss ............................................................................................. 7.09

Muenster .................................................................................... 7.09

Mozzarella ............................................................................... 7.09

Provolone .................................................................................. 7.09

Smoked Gouda ....................................................................... 7.09

Smoked Nova Lox .............................................................. 28.00