Hungry now?

Call ahead to order!

516-541-7415

Quality like this can't be outsourced!

Stuff A Bagel logo

CATERING PLATTERS

 

Cheese Platter

An assortment of sliced and cubed cheeses attractively displayed with gourmet crackers

15-20 People $59.95

 

Vegetable Crudite Platter

An extravagant assortment of fresh cut vegetables on a platter, served with a ranchlblue cheese dressing

15-20 People $49.95

 

Antipasto Platter

An assortment of italian meats and cheeses, grilled vegetables, grilled chicken , roasted peppers, olives, marinated artichoke hearts & fried eggplant w/ balsamic dressing on the side

15-20 People $79.95

 

Fresh Fruit Platter

Fresh seasonal fruits, attractively displayed on a platter

15-20 People $69.95

 

Tomato Mozzarella Platter

Fresh made sliced mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, basil and italian dressing

15-20 People $79.95

 

Grilled Vegetable Platter

Yellow and green squash, eggplant, red and green peppers, carrots and onions. All seasoned and char-grilled to perfection. beautifully arranged on a platter.

15-20 People $54.95

 

Mini Bagel Lunch Platter

$7.50 Per Person Minimum of 10 People

Stuffed mini bagels with choice of salads & meats, displayed on a decorated platter

* Includes: 2 mini bagels per person, potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, condiments & paper goods

 

Cold Buffet Platter

$9.95 Per Person Minimum of 10 People

Select 4 Boar's Head meats and 2 cheeses: roast beef, turkey breast, ham, salami, corned beef, pastrami, pepperoni, cappicolla, bologna, American, Swiss, muenster, provolone, mozzarella & cheddar

* Includes: Cold cuts on a decorated platter, potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, pickle & olive tray, rolls & rye bread on a platter, condiments & paper goods

all prices subject to change w/out notice.

 

Wrap Platter

$8.49 Per Person

A beautiful variety of overstuffed wrap sandwiches on a decorated platter with your choice of cold cuts, cheeses and homemade salads

 

Rugelach Platter

$10.99 Per Pound

Choose from our chocolate, cinnamon raisin or raspberry rugelach arranged on a decorative platter

 

Sheet Cakes

Half Sheet $29.99

Crumb cake, raspberry crumb cake, chocolate crumb cake, moist brownies with chocolate fudge topped with your choice of chocolate chips, walnuts or sprinkles

Stuff a Bagel can certainly set your party up with a delicious assortment of sandwiches and appetizers, but we also offer delicious home-baked pastries! Think of us for fresh rugelach, muffins, cookies, sheet cakes and brownies.

You'll be the hero

If you have an army to feed on a civilian budget, Stuff a Bagel's hero sandwiches are just the thing for you!  

 

Available in 3-6 foot lengths, each foot of sandwich serves 4-5 people. We use Boar's Head cold cuts. Our giant party bagels are always a hit too!

 -  Corporate accounts welcome    

 -  We deliver to all businesses, homes or banquet facilities in Massapequa

 -  Call your order in or stop by our store in Carman's Plaza/DMV Shopping Center

You bring the guests, we'll do the rest

Square Square Square

"This is a good bagel store, everything is so fresh. The sandwiches are good and the prices are cheap."

- Stacey T.

FREE DELIVERY

"The people here make you feel like family. I won't buy bagels anywhere else but Stuff a Bagel."

- Gus O.

Don't forget the sweet stuff

From working lunches to special occasions, Stuff a Bagel offers a variety of delicious menu options that are sure to please everyone on the guest list. Our antipasto platters, wrap stations and mini-bagel stations are all made to order and delivered fresh!

We work hard so you can work smart

Square Fruit platter

Catering Menu

GIANT PARTY BAGELS

• 2 ft serves 10-12 guests • 3 ft. serves 18-22 guests

* Includes macaroni salad, potato salad and cole slaw 

 

American Party Bagel

• 2 ft. $59.95 -  • 3 ft. $69.95

Roast beef, turkey, genoa salami, ham, bologna, American cheese, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Italian Party Bagel

• 2 ft. $59.95 -  • 3 ft. $69.95

Genoa salami, pepperoni, cappy ham, bologna, ham, provolone and mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Nova Party Bagel

• 2 ft. $74.95 -  • 3 ft. $84.95

Nova cream cheese on platter with onions and tomatoes.

PARTY HEROS

• Serves 4 to 5 people per foot • Available in 3 ft., 4 ft. , 5ft., and 6 ft.

• All heroes include macaroni salad, potato salad and cole slaw

 

American Hero

$16.95 Per Foot

Roast beef, turkey, ham, bologna, genoa salami, Swiss cheese, American cheese, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Italian Hero

$16.95 Per Foot

Genoa salami, pepperoni, cappy ham, bologna, ham, provolone and mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Kosher Style Hero

$17.95 Per Foot

(Non-Kosher) Roast beef, turkey, corned beef, pastrami, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Chicken Cutlet Hero

$18.95 Per Foot

(Grilled or Fried) Chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, mozzarella, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Chicken Cutlet Supreme Hero

$18.95 Per Foot

(Grilled or Fried) Chicken cutlet, mozzarella, bacon, lettuce and tomatoes

 

BBQ Skirt Steak Hero

$22.95 Per Foot

Marinated grilled skirt steak with caramelized onions, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomatoes

 

Grilled Vegetable Hero

$18.95 Per Foot

Grilled zucchini, squash, portobello mushrooms, carrots, eggplant and onions with a balsamic vinaigrette

 

Roast Beef Hero

$18.95 Per Foot

House seasoned roast beef, muenster cheese, oven roasted chipotle mayonnaise

BREAKFAST CATERING

 

Hot Breakfast Buffet

$10.95 Per Person Minimum 15 People

Scrambled Eggs, Homefries, Butter, Maple Syrup, French Toast, Bagels, Jelly, Orange Juice, Bacon & Sausage (Patties), Muffins & Danish, Assorted Cream Cheeses, Coffee Set-Up

* Includes: Loan of chafing dish racks, sternos, plates, serving spoons, forks, knives, napkins, cups, milk, sugar, sweetener, & stirrers

 

Cream Cheese Platter

$5.25 Per Person Minimum of 10 People

Choose any 4 of our homemade flavors

* Includes: 2 bagels per person, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion on a decorated platter

 

Mini Bagel Breakfast Platter

$4.25 Per Person Minimum of 10 People

Cream cheese and/or butter on mini bagels, cut & displayed on a platter

* Includes: 2 mini bagels per person and paper goods

 

Nova Lox Platter

$13.95 Per Person Minimum of 10 People

Per 10 people you will receive 3 1/2 lbs of fish

* Includes: sliced Nova, lettuce, tomato & onion on a decorated platter, a cream cheese platter (choose any 4 of our homemade flavors), 2 bagels per person & paper goods

 

Bakery Platter

Assorted Cookies, Brownies, Muffins, Crumb Cake, Danish & Pastries, Arranged on a Platter.

Small size serves up to 12 people - $24.95

Large size serves up to 25 people - $49.95

 

Coffee / Tea Set-Up

$1.49 per person Minimum of 20 people

Regular coffee, decaf coffee & assorted flavored teas

* Includes: Cups, milk, half & half, sugar, sweetener & stirrers

 

Coffee To Go

Grab and Go: Serves 12 People $15.95

* Includes: Cups, milk, sugar, sweetener & stirrers

GOURMET SALADS

 

Tossed Salads

Half Tray 7-10 People $24.95

Full Tray 15-20 People $34.95

Tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, red onions, romaine lettuce

 

Greek Salads

Half Tray 7-10 People $29.95

Full Tray 15-20 People $44.95

Olives, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese, romaine lettuce

 

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

Half Tray 7-10 People $29.95

Full Tray 15-20 People $44.95

Grilled chicken, croutons, parmesan cheese, romaine lettuce

*All salads from our menu with romaine lettuce or Mesciun mix can be made to order

 

Half Tray 7-10 People $29.95

Full Tray 15-20 People $44.95

 

Make any of our Specialty Salads into Salad Trays

1/2 Tray: $29.95

Full Tray: $49.95

 

*All dressings to accompany salads are on the side*

 

Salad Platters

$9.95 Per Person Minimum of 10 People

Choose any 4 of our fresh homemade salads: Tuna, lite vegetable tuna, chicken, egg, shrimp, seafood, whitefish, cranberry apple chicken salad

* Includes: Your selection of salads on a decorated platter with lettuce, tomato & onion, 2 bagels per person, potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, pickle & olive tray, condiments & paper goods.

Cheese Platter Antipasto Platter Fresh Fruit Platter Tomato Mozzarella Platter Tossed Salad